John Derbyshire Says: If You Think Donald Trump Is Adolf Hitler, You’re Nuts
Print Friendly and PDF
[Adapted from the latest Radio Derb, now available exclusively on]

This year—I just have time to notice!—marks the 25th birthday of Godwin's Law.

In case you don't know Godwin's Law, here's the background. The internet was the plaything of academics and government types until 1989, when the first dial-up access was made available to general users. Just one year later, in 1990, Mike Godwin formulated Godwin's Law, a universal principle describing the behavior of online discussion groups.

That was 25 years ago.

Godwin's Law, in its original form, says the following thing:

As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches one.
A probability of one is, of course, certainty.

Well, the latest manifestation of Godwin's Law showed up this week in—would you believe it?—The New York Times. This was an Op-Ed column by Roger Cohen[Email him] in the December 14th edition of the Gray Lady. Title of the column: Trump's Weimar America.

"Weimar" here is short for the Weimar Republic, the constitutional order under which Germany was governed between 1919 and 1933, before the Nazi Party came to power.

That's Roger Cohen's thesis: Today's U.S.A., he's saying, is the Weimar Republic. Donald Trump is Adolf Hitler.

Just to remind you: This is The New York Times, America's premier broadsheet newspaper.

Here's a sample of Cohen's argument.

The Weimar Republic ended with a clown's ascent to power, a high-energy buffoon who shouted loudest, a bully from the beer halls, a racist and a bigot. He was an outsider given to theatrics and pageantry. He seduced the nation of Beethoven. He took the world down with him.
This is such low-grade stuff, it's wearisome to have to deal with it. Somebody has to, though, so here goes.

First off, as I said, writing about this same tedious topic five years ago, Hitler's Germany does not map into any large tendency in modern American politics. Some particular components of it map into localized phenomena; but even when this happens, it is usually to some similar feature of our political Left.

Take the universities, for example. In Weimar Germany they were bastions of Nazism. I'm going to quote myself again, this time from my book Prime Obsession, page 255. The subject here is the university town of Göttingen, a great center of mathematical excellence in the 19th and early 20th centuries of which I wrote that

Göttingen at large was rather strong for Hitler. This was true of both "town" and "gown." In the 1930 elections, Göttingen had delivered twice as many votes to Hitler's party as the national average; and the Nazis had a majority in the university's student congress as far back as 1926.
The politicization of the Academy was a key part of Hitler's program, as it has been a key part of the modern American Left's program. In both cases it has been very successful.

So if it's parallels with the Weimar Republic that Roger Cohen seeks, perhaps he should visit our university campuses.

For that matter, the quasi-pagan nature worship characteristic of Nazi culture has resurfaced in far-Left environmental and animal-rights groups. Hitler would have been a great enthusiast for climate-change alarmism.

Antisemitism is more complicated. The biggest coherent groups of anti-Semites in the U.S.A. today are blacks and Muslims, two groups that are situated pretty solidly on the political Left.

There's antisemitism on the nationalist Right, too, though, of course. You don't need to tell me, I know all about it. As an anti-anti-Semite myself, with a long paper trail in evidence of that, I get emails sneering at me for cowardice because I stubbornly refuse to "name the Jew."

Yes, there are anti-Semites in the Dissident Right, plenty of them. But there are plenty of us anti-anti-Semites too, though; not to mention a fair number of Jews. The last Dissident-Right function I attended was the annual conference of the H.L. Mencken Club in November. The speaker roster at that event included Bob Weissberg, Ed Rubenstein, Carl Horowitz, and the club's founder Paul Gottfried.

But, hey, don't take my word for it: The Mencken Club publishes online audio of conference speeches. American Renaissance publishes online video of their conferences. Check 'em out for yourself; and if you spot an anti-Semitic rant, let me know.

And, by the way, none of the following is anti-Semitic in any way I understand the word.

  • Calling out individual Jews like Roger Cohen when they write dumb things.
  • Noticing that the very high average IQ of Ashkenazi Jews brings them disproportionate representation in a lot of intellectual fields.
  • Criticizing the immigration romanticism that is widespread—not universal, but widespread—among American Jews: the belief that what was good for America back in the Grover Cleveland administration is good for America today, in wildly different circumstances.
  • Pointing out the hypocrisy of ethnocentric Jews squealing in horror at expressions of ethnocentrism by white gentiles.
  • Wondering why, since it was a white gentile-dominated America that encouraged mass settlement of Jews in the first place, expressions of collective gratitude seem to be far outnumbered by expressions of collective hostility.
What does any of that have to do with Donald Trump, anyway? The blogger who calls himself "Lion of the Blogosphere" had an interesting post about this the other day. Quote:
If Trump becomes president he will be the most culturally Jewish president in American history. His daughter is Jewish, and probably a plurality of his top employees are Jewish. His CFO Allen Weisselberg and his top lawyers Alan Garten and Jason Greenblatt (Yeshiva University graduate) are likely Jewish based on their last names. As well as his attorney and Executive Vice President Michael Cohen who often represents Trump on TV interviews and his previous general counsel Bernie Diamond. And Cathy Hoffman Glosser, his EVP of Global Licensing. And Eric Danziger, the CEO of the Trump Hotel Collection. And the old guy who worked for him on his TV Show, George Ross. And of course his own daughter who is his EVP of Development and Acquisitions.

Also, Trump once served as the grand marshal of the Salute to Israel Parade.

Irony Of Trump And White Nationalists, December 14, 2015

There are a great many things you can say about all this.

But if the thing you want to say is that Donald Trump maps onto Adolf Hitler, and Trump's supporters map onto the Nazi Party of Weimar Germany, then I'm afraid I'm going to have to say:

"You're nuts."

John Derbyshire [email him] writes an incredible amount on all sorts of subjects for all kinds of outlets. (This no longer includes National Review, whose editors had some kind of tantrum and fired him. ) He is the author of We Are Doomed: Reclaiming Conservative Pessimism and several other books. He's had two books published by FROM THE DISSIDENT RIGHT (also available in Kindle) and From the Dissident Right II: Essays 2013. His writings are archived at

Readers who wish to donate (tax deductible) funds specifically earmarked for John Derbyshire's writings at can do so here.


Print Friendly and PDF